If
a law firm sends a letter seeking to collect the correct amount, from the
correct consumer, on behalf of the correct creditor, can the consumer still
sue, claiming the firm violated the FDCPA because no attorney was “meaningfully
involved” in preparing the letter? The
Sixth Circuit recently held the answer is “no” in Buchholz
Simmonds & Narita LLP Blogs
Blog Authors
Latest from Simmonds & Narita LLP
Why Every Lawyer And Client Should Be Fighting To Stop The "Meaningful Attorney Involvement" Doctrine From Spreading
Few things are more fundamental in the law than the principle that a lawyer owes a duty of loyalty to the client, a duty to be vigorous advocate within the bounds of the law, and a duty to maintain the client’s confidences and preserve the attorney-client privilege. Clients expect this of their attorneys, as they…
Trends In FDCPA Litigation Filed Against HOA Attorneys
Attorneys who regularly engage in collection work for community
associations have increasingly become
targets for lawsuits filed by professional consumer attorneys under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (“FDCPA” or “the Act”), 15 U.S.C. § 1692 et. seq., and analogous state laws.
These suits can be costly, distracting, and can create significant
tensions between HOA…
Is It “Debt Collection” If You Never Asked For Money?
Can a communication from a collector violate the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1692, et. seq. (the “FDCPA”) if it never asks the debtor to pay any money? What exactly does the term “debt collection” mean in the context of the FDCPA? These seemingly
simple questions have divided
the circuit courts,…
Emerging Trends In FDCPA Litigation Against Community Association Attorneys
Attorneys and other entities
that regularly engage
in collection work for community associations may be subject to the requirements of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, 15 U.S.C.
§ 1692 et. seq., as well as analogous state laws governing the consumer collection process. Practitioners should
be aware of numerous FDCPA decisions issued during the past…
Is A Bank A “Debt Collector” Under California’s Rosenthal Act? Maybe Not.
Can a bank
be sued for acting as a “debt collector” under the California Rosenthal Act? You are probably tempted to answer “yes” it
can, because you know the Act defines a “debt collector” to include an entity
that is collecting on behalf of itself or on behalf of third parties. …
Searching For The Meaning Of “Meaningful Involvement”
Grappling
with the meaning of the so-called “meaningful involvement” doctrine is one of
the most elusive and frustrating compliance challenges for collection attorneys
and their clients. What exactly must a
collection attorney do to ensure they are “meaningfully involved” in a file
before sending a collection letter to a consumer? When, if ever,…
For Attorneys Representing Community Associations: A Primer On FDCPA Class Actions And How To Avoid Them
(This post is adopted from the materials presented at the CAI Law Seminar in Las Vegas, Nevada on January 20, 2017)
Demystifying the
FDCPA Class Action For HOA Attorneys
Consumer
attorneys have been filing FDCPA class actions against collection attorneys for
decades, and the pace of those filings has increased sharply in…
The “Least Sophisticated Debtor” Is Getting More Sophisticated, And Has An Improved Memory Too
When collectors
get sued in an FDCPA action, they face a steep uphill battle. Courts apply the very pro-consumer “least
sophisticated debtor” standard when evaluating a collector’s communications,
and most violations of the Act are “strict liability” – meaning the debtor can
win the case without proving the collector intended to violate the
statute. Recently,…
Consent Order Compliance: Navigating The CFPB’s Unofficial “Rules” Governing Debt Collection
The
CFPB has entered into consent orders with major creditors, debt buyers and law
firms during the past year relating to key areas of their collection
practices. The consent orders impose
significant new requirements relating to data integrity, dispute handling, debt
substantiation, debt sales, affidavit practices, and litigation practices. The orders…